The Deep Archives, the gallery selling the Ed Benedict artwork that I wrote about earlier, also has images of the following UPA backgrounds, which have already been sold:

Though these backgrounds certainly look like something from the 1950s, they are actually from a 1945 US Navy training film called THE ROVER BOYS, directed by John Hubley. The background designers on the film were Jules Engel and Herb Klynn, though I don’t know which of them designed and painted these particular backgrounds. During the mid-1940s, most of the American animation industry was still firmly entrenched in an illustrative and realistically rendered approach to background painting. Only a small group of artists — perhaps two dozen at most — were consciously pushing for stylized design at this time, and a good number of them worked at the upstart cartoon studio UPA. I spend some time in the introduction of my book tracing the roots of 1950s animation design and looking at the pioneering animation designers of the 1940s. To get a sense of how radical the ROVER BOYS backgrounds were in comparison to what was happening elsewhere, check out this painting from Disney’s SONG OF THE SOUTH (1946).

Both approaches have their value so the intent here isn’t to say that a stylized background is somehow more valid or better than an illustrative background. But the ROVER BOYS bgs serve as an example of how far artists like Engel and Klynn had drifted apart from their contemporaries during the mid-1940s. Not only are the film’s backgrounds revolutionary in their wholly unrealistic use of color, but they’re also impressive for their restrained use of color. Notice that a lot of the negative space in the backgrounds is created from white areas that have been simply left unpainted, and in the top background, the unpainted white even creates part of the positive space in the form of the hangar roofs. Leaving so much of the background “unfinished” at another studio like Warners or MGM would have surely gotten Engel and Klynn fired, but at UPA, the use of color as a prominent design element was one of the studio’s distinguishing hallmarks from the very beginning.



The hangers are a great example of the artist(s) allowing the viewer’s brain to “fill in the blanks,” so to speak. When I look at this UPA background, I immediately think of two-color printed spot illustrations that were found in cookbooks and pamphlets and other various ephemera of the time. It’s interesting to see how this translates to film, considering that the print artists were doing a lot of the implied negative/positive space stuff out of necessity, to give the illusion that there was more to their illustrations than the limited palette gave initially gave them. I’d love to see The Rover Boys. Any idea where to view it — some compilation, or anything?
Comment by Ward — November 18, 2005 @ 5:38 am
Those plane designs are something else! Great blog Amid.
Comment by Jason — November 18, 2005 @ 2:16 pm
Yup, I’m the proud owner of these bgs. Thanks Amid, for giving a little background on who was responsible. I’d love to see the short.
Comment by Shannon — November 18, 2005 @ 3:23 pm
Thanks for the thoughtful comment Ward. And thanks for writing Shannon — nice to know who owns these gems. Unfortunately I don’t know where anybody can see the film. I’ve never seen ROVER BOYS either, though I’ve seen the film’s color styling boards and some model sheets from it. There’s dozens of UPA industrial/training films and hundreds of the studio’s commercials that are essentially lost, and the only way to see them is if you know film collectors who have prints (which is how I’ve seen a lot of them). The funny thing is that you could release most of these films too since they’re public domain.
Comment by Amid — November 21, 2005 @ 4:18 am
Yeah, those UPA backgrounds are terrific. Amazingly graphic (even for today) and great colors too. I’d love to see Rover Boys myself. Nice find.
Comment by Daniel — November 22, 2005 @ 7:15 am